-
Re: The Burn Book: A True Story
Not really a lot to say after that last review, but just thought I'd say; good job! This was great. It's bad that it actually happened, of course, but as ...
Mar 13, 2009 -
Re: On Orcs
A being in Tolkien's legendarium of far greater power and evil than Sauron, Morgoth, is supposed to be Tolkien's equivalent of Satan, so it could be argued, therefore, that the ...
Feb 7, 2009 -
Re: My Poetry-Mist
I really liked this. I'm assuming that when you say "foreign" you mean "strange" or "unfamiliar"? If you are using it to mean "possible", then I would suggest doing as ...
Feb 6, 2009 -
Re: Last Summer
I liked this, though if I'm brutally honest I wouldn't consider it to be exceptional. The reason for that is there aren't many good things I actually feel like commenting ...
Jan 26, 2009 -
Re: Unrealistic Circumstances
I quite liked this - don't worry about the lack of rhymes, a poem doesn't need to rhyme. The lack of punctuation might hurt some people's fweelings. Personally, I didn't ...
Jan 26, 2009 -
Re: ALove amongst the spheres delivers the mountain & the me
There's something very special about this poem. I don't know what, maybe it's the slight abstractness of it, maybe it's the fact that it's on a huge level (if taken ...
Jan 12, 2009 -
Re: Love <3
Welcome to YWS! Firstly, it's worth saying that love poems are very common on YWS, so it's difficult to post one here and get an excellent review. Many people here ...
Jan 9, 2009 -
Re: Glass Castle
I quite liked this poem, but I wasn't sure what to make of the structure. It seemed a bit all over the place - which doesn't have to be a ...
Dec 30, 2008 -
Re: Bubbly
Well that's......different. It's comical, yet still tragic enough to make me feel sorry for this fishophiliac (is that an okay alternative spelling?). It's also somewhat horrifying. However, I have to
Dec 30, 2008 -
Re: Streetlamp Heroes
Knowing that this wasn't written with any purpose other than to express yourself, I like this poem. I don't get much from it, though, but I like the comparisons between ...
Dec 28, 2008 -
Re: I Believe In God
I'm an Atheist, and I liked this poem. Admittedly, it is making me want to go on a rant in defence of my Atheism (probably not your intention), though I ...
Dec 19, 2008 -
Re: When Will This Moment Stop
I reality like this poem, though I'm not sure if my interpretation of it is correct. Am I right in thinking it's describing the last few moments of a time ...
Dec 12, 2008 -
Re: What is this feeling?
This was good-as far as I'm concerned, you can't go wrong with poetry anyway. But you said you're looking for advice, and nine people so far seem to have ignored ...
Nov 30, 2008 -
Re: Behind the Trees
I have to say, I'm quite impressed-are you really 13?! This looks more like something someone my age would write! A couple of small things to do with convention-generally, punctuation ...
Nov 28, 2008 -
Re: Fission - [Edited]
I think you should ignore mike's comment on the place names. I'm guessing a large number of Indians know about Gondwanaland, the Monazite desert and Kerala? If that is the ...
Nov 28, 2008
